SMT High Speed Mounter Comparison Table (Cellular Phone with 0201chips)

High Speed Mounter Comparison Table (Cellular Phone with 0201chips)

High Speed Mounter Comparison Table (DVD)         
Big Machine (Longer Life Time and Better Placement Accuracy)
Brand/ ModelSpec. CPH Cycle Time CPH Actual CPH (with M/C ajustment, stability and PM downtime)Price (HKD) JPY = 0.06769Spec. CPH/ PriceActual CPH / Price Life Time Throughput/ Price RatioMajor Weakness
Panasonic
CM602100,00070,00059,5003,895,0000.02570.01530.01531.Derate CPH for component 0201, 2. Asustec has over 200 sets 3. Price included 8mm feeder 160pcs, 4. need more feeders
CM402MA60,00042,00035,7002,562,5000.02340.01390.01391.Derate CPH for component 0201, 2. CM402 is discontinue product, 3. Price included 8mm feeder 160pcs, 4. need more feeders
BM12330,00016,50012,375870,0000.03450.01420.00851. Made in Suzhou, 2. Machine Stability issue, 3. Price included 8mm feeder 40pcs, 4. Need more feeders, 5. Placement accuracy issue
Fuji
NXT(4x M3s)66,00046,20042,5042,400,0000.02750.01770.0177Price included 80 pcs 8mm feeders
NXT(6x M3s)99,00069,30063,7563,600,0000.02750.01770.0177Price included 120 pcs 8mm feeders
XP143E (50 slots)21,80015,26014,039870,0000.02510.01610.0161Price included 40 pcs 8mm feeder
Siemens
X480,00048,00040,8004,300,0000.01860.00950.00951. Bad CPH/ Price, 2. Weak in Flexibility
HS6060,00036,00030,6002,800,0000.02140.01090.01091. Stability issue, 2. Discontinue product (will replace by X and D series machine, 3. Price included 80pcs 8mm feeder, 4. Need more PM time, 5. High PM cost
S2727,00017,55014,9181,500,0000.01800.00990.00991.Bad CPH/Price ratio, 2. Price included 80pcs 8mm feeder
Assembleon
AX-501150,000105,00089,2506,500,0000.02310.01370.01371. Price included 100 pcs 8mm feeder, 2. Long product change over time, high M/C downtime
AX-30190,00063,00053,5504,000,0000.02250.01340.01341. Bad product change over time, 2. Price included 100 pcs 8mm feeder
Universal
Quadrix80,00056,00047,6002,900,0000.02760.01640.01641. Price included 80pcs 8mm feeder
AC-3030,00018,00015,3001,330,0000.02260.01150.01151.Right now made in US, plan made in SZ Shehou, 2. Price included 50pcs 8mm feeder
AC-72(GSM1)18,500 (chips), 6,500(IC)11,1009,4351,320,0000.01400.00710.00711. Can change head, made in Shehou, 2.
Genesis GC-6057,142 36,363 (IPC9850)27,27223,1812,500,0000.02290.00930.0093Can change head
Hitachi
GXH80,00056,00047,6002,900,0000.02760.01640.01641. Price included 80pcs 8mm feeder
Sony
G20045,00022,50015,7501,200,0000.03750.01310.0092Machine stability issue, and efficiency issue
Mid Range Machine (Shorter Life Time and Placement Accuracy Issue)
Juki
KE2050CM13,2009,2407,854440,0000.03000.01790.01071. Laser vision need to change around 2.5 years(HKD70K/ 5 years); 2. High electricity cost (3KVA/ machine), 3. Derate CPH for 0201, 5. 2050 is discontinue product , will be replace by 2070, 6. Price include 40pcs 8mm feeder, 7. Need more feeders
KE2050R13,2009,2407,854512,5000.02580.01530.00921. Laser vision need to change around 2.5 years(HKD70K/ 5 years); 2. High electricity cost for CPH (3KVA/ machine), 3. Derate for 0201, 4. 2050 is discontinue product , will be replace by 2070, 6. Price include 40pcs 8mm feeder, 7. Need more feeder
FX-1R25,00015,00012,750922,5000.02710.01380.00831. Machine stability issue, 3. Derate for 0201 chips, 4. Price include 80pcs 8mm feeder, 5. Need more feeder
SamSung
CP6330,000(IPC9850)18,00013,500650,0000.04620.02080.01041. Machine Stability Issue, 2. Short Life time, 3. Bad placement performance for 0201, 4. Price included 90pcs 8mm feeder, 5. Need more feeder
CP4514,900(IPC9850)8,9406,705550,0000.02710.01220.00611. Machine Stability Issue, 2. Short Life time, 3. Price included 90pcs 8mm feeder, 4. Need more feeder
SM31030,000(IPC9850)18,00013,5001,000,0000.03000.01350.00671. Machine stability issue, 2. Short Life time 3. Price include 120 pcs 8mm feeder, 4. Need more feeder
SM32030,000(IPC9850), 45x45mm IC18,00013,5001,100,0000.02730.01230.0061Not stable
Yamaha
YG20045,00027,00022,9501,332,5000.03380.01720.00861.Machine stability, 2. Short Life time 3. Bad placement performance for 0402 inch (reject rate more then 10k), 4. Main machine HKD1.15M , 5. Price included 80pcs 8mm feeder, HKD1,700/8mm feeder, 7. Need more feeder
YV100xgp16,2009,7208,262530,0000.03060.01560.00781.Machine stability, 2. Short Life time, 3. Limitation components range, size and height, 4. Price included 20pcs 8mm feeder, 5. Need more feeder
Note:
1. Please multiply by 1.05 to 1.1 of Fuji price, when you verbally tell customer and noted about the JPY currency change
2. Cycle Time CPH is the CPH included PCB loading time and fiducial mark
3. Actual CPH include PCB loading time, fiducial mark, PM time, ajustment, feeder replenishment and minor repairing excluded product change
4. Big machine life time assume 10 years, the index is 1

Note: 
1. Please multiply by 1.05 to 1.1 of Fuji price, when you verbally tell customer and noted about the JPY currency change
2. Cycle Time CPH is the CPH included PCB loading time and fiducial mark
3. Actual CPH is included PCB loading time, fiducial mark, PM time, ajustment, feeder replenishment and minor repairing excluded product change
4. Big machine life time assume 10 years, the index is 1

About SMThelp

We design and manufacture Odd Form component auto insertion machine,SMT equipment, and providing spare parts service. Worldwide Installation and on site support and training.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *